Every year, college rankings invite families to ask a familiar question: Which colleges are the best?
But The Princeton Review’s newly released Best Colleges for 2027 rankings offer a useful reminder that there are many different ways to define “best.”
Rather than placing colleges on a single hierarchical list, The Princeton Review surveyed 172,000 students at 392 colleges about their experiences and used those responses to create 50 different ranking lists. The colleges themselves represent a select group: according to The Princeton Review, the 392 featured schools comprise only about 14% of America’s nearly 2,800 four-year colleges.
The results highlight aspects of the undergraduate experience that can be difficult to capture through traditional measures of prestige, selectivity, and academic reputation:
- Best Classroom Experience: Reed College
- Best-Run Colleges: Claremont McKenna College
- Best Career Services: Bentley University
- Best Student Support and Counseling Services: Macalester College
- Best Campus Food: University of Massachusetts Amherst
- Best College Dorms: Bowdoin College
- Most Beautiful Campus: University of San Diego
- Friendliest Students: William & Mary
- Happiest Students: Vanderbilt University
- Great Outdoors: Students Get Outside: The University of the South
What makes these rankings especially useful isn’t determining whether Vanderbilt is “better” than Bowdoin or Reed. It’s that they encourage students to think more carefully about what they actually want their college experience to look like.
Prestige Matters. But It Doesn’t Tell the Whole Story.
For many ambitious students and their families, reputation matters, and understandably so.
Academic caliber, selectivity, faculty, alumni networks, graduate school placement, and career opportunities are all reasonable factors to consider when building a college list. A highly regarded institution can offer extraordinary resources, peers, networks, and opportunities.
But prestige alone cannot tell a student what it will feel like to spend four years there.
Rob Franek, Editor-in-Chief of The Princeton Review and lead author of The Best 392 Colleges, makes an important distinction in explaining the philosophy behind the rankings: The Princeton Review does not name one college “best” overall. Instead, the goal is to help applicants answer a much more personal—and ultimately more consequential—question:
Which college is best for me?
For students aiming at the most selective colleges in the country, that question matters just as much as Where can I get in?
Start With the Student, Not the Ranking
Imagine three students with similarly strong academic records and ambitions.
One wants intense intellectual engagement, small classes, and professors who will challenge their thinking. Another is already focused on internships, recruiting, and preparing for a career. A third cares deeply about school spirit, friendships, and finding a campus community where students seem genuinely happy.
Those students shouldn’t necessarily have identical college lists.
And yet, one of the easiest traps in the college search is to begin with a collection of prestigious institutions and work backward: Which of these schools could I get into?
A more thoughtful process begins with the student.
What kind of classroom brings out their best thinking? How do they like to spend their time outside of class? Do they want a large university or an intimate college? A city or a college town? Intense school spirit or a more independent culture? How important are undergraduate research, career preparation, outdoor recreation, residential life, or access to professors?
And, yes, how important are reputation, selectivity, alumni networks, and career outcomes?
There is nothing wrong with caring about those things. The point is to understand how they fit alongside the other qualities that will shape a student’s day-to-day college experience.
Only then can families begin identifying colleges that deliver the particular combination of opportunities a student values.
Use College Rankings as Clues, Not Answers
No ranking can tell a student where they will thrive.
But rankings can be extremely useful research tools when families understand what they actually measure.
A student who cares deeply about the undergraduate classroom experience might take a closer look at Reed after seeing its Princeton Review distinction. A student focused on career preparation could investigate what Bentley is doing particularly well. Someone who imagines spending weekends hiking, climbing, or exploring might want to understand why students at Sewanee report such a strong outdoor culture.
And a student interested in Vanderbilt shouldn’t simply note that its students are among the happiest. The more useful question is: Why?
The ranking shouldn’t be the conclusion. It should prompt the next round of research.
Why do students say this? What programs, traditions, resources, or aspects of campus culture contribute to that experience? Would those same qualities matter to me?
These questions can lead families beyond the most familiar names. Just as importantly, they can reveal meaningful differences among highly selective institutions that might otherwise look remarkably similar on paper.
Building a Smarter College List
The takeaway isn’t that students should choose “fit over prestige,” as though the two are mutually exclusive.
The strongest college lists often incorporate both.
A student can care about academic reputation, ambitious peers, powerful alumni networks, and strong outcomes and pay attention to teaching, campus culture, student happiness, advising, and quality of life.
In fact, the most thoughtful college search isn’t about lowering aspirations. It’s about becoming more precise about them.
Instead of simply asking, What’s the highest-ranked college I could attend? students should be asking:
What do I want from these four years? And which colleges offer that experience at the highest level?
Answering that question takes more than scrolling through rankings. It requires understanding a student’s academic strengths, intellectual interests, personality, ambitions, and priorities, and then knowing the college landscape well enough to identify institutions where those qualities can translate into both a compelling candidacy and an exceptional undergraduate experience.
A More Strategic Approach to College Admissions
That’s the work at the heart of Top Tier Admissions’ Private Counseling program.
Our Senior Private Counselors work one-on-one with ambitious students and their families throughout the college admissions journey. Beginning as early as seventh grade, we help students make strategic choices about academics, extracurricular pursuits, summer opportunities, testing, and the development of authentic scholarly interests. As application season approaches, that long-term work informs a carefully considered college list and a cohesive application strategy.
The goal isn’t simply to assemble a list of impressive names—or to chase a ranking.
It’s to understand what makes a student distinctive, help them become the strongest applicant they can be, and identify exceptional colleges where their interests, ambitions, and talents can flourish.
Because ultimately, a successful college admissions process isn’t simply about getting into a prestigious college. It’s about having the strategy, perspective, and self-knowledge to know which exceptional colleges are worth striving for in the first place.
Ready to build a thoughtful, strategic college admissions plan for your student? Connect with our team to learn more about our Private Counseling program.
Stay Connected for More Expert Guidance
Want to stay in the loop? Follow us on Instagram @toptieradmissions and subscribe to our blog for expert advice and admissions insights.
Know someone else navigating the college admissions process? Pass it along, they’ll thank you later!
