If you’re applying to Cornell University, which has multiple undergraduate colleges, it can be hard to navigate the admissions process and understand what the university is truly looking for in applicants. To help demystify the process, we spoke with Heidi Steinmetz Lovette, a former Assistant Director of Admissions at Cornell and a Senior Private Counselor at Top Tier Admissions, who offered an insider’s perspective on how applications are reviewed, what makes a candidate stand out, and the common mistakes that can hold applicants back. Whether you’re a high school student dreaming of spending four years in Ithaca or a parent trying to support the process, this interview offers invaluable insights from someone who’s made decisions at the admissions desk.
Can you start by telling us a bit about your role at Cornell and what your day-to-day looked like as an Assistant Director of Admissions?
Absolutely! A large part of my role was centered around reading and evaluating applications, and that work followed two distinct phases: Early Decision (ED) and Regular Decision (RD). In the ED round, we were looking at students who had made Cornell their clear first choice, and I had the pleasure of spending more time with those applications to understand the students’ experiences and fit. It was deeply reflective work, and was my favorite time of the year. RD brought a much larger applicant pool with more variety, and it was about shaping the rest of the class—thinking about balance across multiple factors and reading at a much faster pace. It was intense to make decisions on thousands of applications each year but felt meaningful because of the impact each decision carried.
Outside of reading season, the job looked very different. In summer and fall, we focused on recruitment, hosting information sessions for students and families visiting Ithaca. In the spring, the focus turned toward yield efforts to matriculate the students we had admitted, planning events and working with faculty and student ambassadors.
I also led communications efforts, from email campaigns to print materials, and managed special projects—one favorite was developing an interactive online campus map that let students explore Cornell virtually. The rhythm of the role changed seasonally, and I loved the mix and annual arc of work.
Cornell is known for having multiple undergraduate colleges – how does this impact how applications are reviewed? Is it important for students to tailor their application to a specific college?
Yes—this is one of the most important things applicants need to understand. Admissions at Cornell is decentralized and each undergraduate college at Cornell has its own admissions team, so your application is reviewed entirely within the context of that specific college. That means that your application has to speak directly to the academic culture and priorities of the college you’re applying to rather than to Cornell at a more general level.
The Cornell-specific supplemental essay plays a major role here. I often read the Cornell essay before the Common App personal statement because it gave an immediate sense of whether a student had done their homework. Cornell’s College of Arts & Sciences is known for having one of the longest “Why Us” prompts—up to 650 words—and that’s intentional. The prompts are carefully worded, and even something as subtle as using “academic interests” in the plural versus “interest” in the singular signals that Cornell is looking for intellectually curious students who think across disciplines and have curiosity that spans multiple areas.
So yes, students absolutely need to tailor their application—not just to Cornell generally, but to the college and major they’re choosing. When students got that right, it was immediately clear.
TTA Top Tip: Need help tailoring your supplemental essays or crafting a powerful Personal Statement? Check out our College Essay Guidance Program!
Cornell receives tens of thousands of applications each year. What really makes a student stand out in the sea of qualified applicants?
First, they have to be academically ready—there’s no getting around that. But once that baseline is met, which is true for most applicants, we looked at how students made use of their opportunities. One key concept we considered was “distance traveled.” Did the student lean into the resources available to them? That might mean taking a challenging course load at a school with lots of APs or, alternatively, self-studying or finding enrichment opportunities when those weren’t available.
Certainly there are fields and activities that are more common, and others that stand out as being more unusual, but admissions officers have seen just about everything already, so rather than trying to be intentionally quirky or unusual, students who had fallen in love with something – and gone deep with it – stood out the most.
And related to tailoring, the students who really knew Cornell stood out because they could clearly connect their own experiences and interests to what Cornell could offer them next. It showed us they weren’t just applying to a name, but to a place they saw themselves contributing to and continuing to grow.
What are the biggest mistakes you saw students make in their applications?
The most frequent and avoidable mistake was a lack of research because students were applying to too many schools casually rather than focusing on doing an excellent job on fewer. Every year, I would see students write about wanting to attend Cornell because of proximity to internships and opportunities in New York City—when, in reality, Cornell is in New York state but in Ithaca, far from the city. It made it clear they hadn’t taken even the first step to understanding Cornell. Similarly, students who just parroted the “any person, any study” motto, or fixated on prestige, rankings, or Cornell’s status as an Ivy League university didn’t help their case.
Ultimately, the biggest mistake students made was treating the process like a formula rather than an opportunity to reflect on what they really wanted and how Cornell fit into that picture. The strongest applications were the ones that felt informed, intentional, and genuinely personal. After you’ve seen thousands of applications, there is definitely a “you know it when you see it” aspect to this.
TTA Top Tip: Our personalized counseling for college admissions can help you avoid common mistakes and put your best foot forward in the admissions process.
What does “demonstrating fit” look like at Cornell, and how can a student show that effectively?
“Fit” can be hard to define because Cornell is intentionally broad and inclusive. The motto “Any person, any study” reflects that. But from an admissions standpoint, demonstrating fit means showing how your academic goals align with what Cornell—and specifically your chosen college—can offer. From the admissions side, Cornell is not looking for a specific personality type or extracurricular profile, but alignment between what the student wants to study and what Cornell offers, particularly within the college they’re applying to.
For example, if someone says they want to be a nurse, that’s not a good fit— but only because Cornell doesn’t have a nursing program. Meanwhile, students who showed they understood the academic culture at Cornell, who referenced interdisciplinary learning or specific departments, programs, or faculty stood out. Fit is really about awareness, clarity, and alignment. You don’t need to have it all figured out, but you do need to show that you’ve thought seriously about how to engage on campus and know what you’re stepping into.
What’s one common myth about getting into Cornell that you wish you could bust for students?
A big misconception about Cornell is that students can improve their chances by applying to a “less competitive” college within Cornell—one they’re not especially interested in—just to get their foot in the door. I saw many cases where students tried to game the system by applying to a college they weren’t genuinely interested in, thinking it would be an easier admit. That was a big mistake. The review process is holistic but also highly contextual, and it’s usually easy to tell when someone’s interest isn’t authentic. If your application doesn’t align with the college or major you’re applying to—if, for example, you list an unusual major like viticulture, fashion design, or urban planning —without much background or demonstrated interest in that field, it’s going to be obvious. The colleges review applications independently, and they’re very attuned to whether a student’s interest in their specialties is genuine.
Newer programs or majors with lower historical admit rates aren’t loopholes. The idea that you can game the system by switching colleges once you’re in is also misleading. Internal transfers are possible, but they’re meant for students whose interests evolve while they’re at Cornell.
Bottom line: you should apply to the college and program that most aligns with your genuine interests. That authenticity is what makes an application stand out—and it’s what sets you up to thrive once you get to campus.
If you could give just one piece of advice to a high school student considering Cornell, what would it be?
Apply Early Decision—if Cornell is your first choice. Cornell has always been transparent about the ED advantage and the university now admits approximately half the incoming class through ED. It’s not just about numbers; it’s about signaling to the admissions committee that Cornell is where you want to be. ED allows your application to be seen in a slightly different light—it’s your moment to say, “This is it. This is where I want to be.” That kind of clarity can really matter in a competitive process. And beyond strategy, on campus, there was a cultural shift over the years as more students came through ED. Their level of enthusiasm and sense of belonging grew and I saw more students wearing Cornell gear proudly. If you know Cornell is the place you want to be, applying early is the clearest way to show it and to give yourself the best possible chance.
IS CORNELL THE RIGHT PLACE FOR YOU?
Gaining admission to Cornell isn’t about checking boxes—it’s about crafting an authentic application that reflects who you are, what you care about, and why Cornell is the right place for you. As Heidi emphasized, academic strength is just the starting point. What truly distinguishes successful applicants is their curiosity, intentionality, and depth of research. If Cornell is where your passions and goals align, take the time to demonstrate it—and consider applying Early Decision to give yourself the strongest odds of admission.
Want to stay in the loop? Follow us on Instagram @toptieradmissions and subscribe to our blog for expert advice and admissions insights.
Know someone else navigating the college process? Pass it along — they’ll thank you later!
Kylie’s background includes leading student recruitment and enrollment initiatives, serving as a Founding Member of the Higher Education Advisory Council at Cambridge University Press & Assessment English, and mentoring emerging leaders through coaching.
She holds a Master’s Degree in Liberal Arts and a Leadership Development Certificate from Johns Hopkins, and brings a passion for Positive Psychology and helping individuals navigate meaningful life transitions with confidence and clarity.
- How High School Research Strengthens College Applications - February 26, 2026
- Best College Majors for Career Outcomes - January 22, 2026
- SAT Prep 101: The Ultimate Guide to SAT Practice Tests - December 9, 2025
